Here's the review for those curious, after reading through it again, I think the guy just doesn't like Fallout.
Here's one of the leakers, got his Pipboy edition early for the PS4:
https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/3rvuye/i_had_a_few_things_planned_for_the_weekend_but/cwrsymvThis whole thread is goal, he did say the game was an easy 7.5-8 for him and the only points he agrees on is that the story and a characters were dull. If that's true then I hope the rest of the game holds up. And Peri I already know you're gonna say it, but I honestly wanted more from Bethesda's writing, I'm tired of their same shitty main quest lines and boring as fuck characters, its the reason it killed any interest in Skyrim for me even with mods. But Fallout is a setting I do like exploring in, so I hope the grey tunnels, grey buildings, and probably hours of roaming an empty wasteland will be worth it; because now the 2nd though hype is kicking in where I'm starting to suspect things aren't gonna be as great as it looks.
But hey, here's hoping.